Visitor, The

General | Jan 2019

Reviews

Be Sharp
Reviewed 2019-01-13
FOLK ROCK / COUNTRY ROCK

Neil Young has imagined his work as a file cabinet overfilled with ideas. Not one for cohesion in his albums, Young has produced another grab bag of style & form; as ever this one is intriguing & compelling, but with mixed results. Several tracks offer biting commentary on Donald Trump and on the America that made & tolerates him. Young is backed again by Lukas and Micah Nelson’s (Willie’s sons) band, Promise of the Real.

No FCC issues

1 ** “Already Great” A Canadian’s loving look at an America that’s gone wrong. (5:48)
2 Neil angrily raps while the band merrily bounces along. (2:37)
3 ** It’s the Harvest Moon-style folksinging Neil. Lovely & sad. (4:51)
4 * A “Rockin’ in the USA”-ish anthem for ecology & women’s rights. (5:13)
5 A disjointed ramble about lots of stuff that’s wrong. Fails to make its point. (5:54)
6 Surreal, dreamy images of various carnival acts. Very odd. (8:21)
7 * Slow bluesy chant. A damning observation of what we boomers have left. (2:34)
8 * A call to resistance with full orchestra! Lyrics are a bit lightweight, but heartfelt. (3:25)
9 Low down & bluesy. Fades out with a chant of “lock him up.” (2:00)
10 Neil the folksinger again. A plea on behalf of the Earth with acoustic guitars. (10:32)

Recent airplay

Already Great
Stand Up!Jun 16, 2026
Digging' A Hole
Stand Up!Mar 31, 2026
Already Great
Stand Up! to stop warMar 03, 2026
Already Great
Already Great
Already Great

Charting

2019-01-22 — 2019-03-26
Week EndingAirplays
Mar 17 1
Feb 17 1
Feb 10 2
Feb 3 3
Jan 27 5

Track listing

1. Already Great
2. Fly By Night Deal
3. Almost Always
4. Stand Tall
5. Change Of Heart
6. Carnival
7. Digging' A Hole
8. Children Of Destiny
9. When Bad Got Good
10. Forever