Only God Was Above Us
General
| Apr 2024
Reviews
Francis D
Reviewed 2024-04-08
Reviewed 2024-04-08
“Only God Was Above Us” Vampire Weekend
Vampire Weekend returns with its 5th studio album. The title is taken from a news article about an airliner whose roof blew off during a flight in Hawaii, with a passenger quoted as saying “Only God was above us.” This serves as a metaphor for singer-songwriter Ezra Koenig’s ongoing search for answers to cosmic questions regarding life and purpose. Not quite as melodic as the band’s previous “Father Of The Bride,” the album nevertheless offers a standout collection of instant indie rock and chamber pop classics that integrate exotic rhythms, multiple layers of keys, plus bass and guitar — together with Koenig’s clever, intelligent lyrics exploring wide-ranging aspects of our existence. It’s noisier and more clash-y than their previous albums, but truly, every track is worthy of play. RIYL: Vampire Weekend
— Francis
Highly recommended: 3, 8, 5, 2, 10, 9, 1. FCC on Track 11 (unedited version of track #1).
1. (3:36) Ice Cream Piano (Radio Edit) — Unexpected opener. Almost spoken vocals with a couple of expletives, set over distortion and deliberate piano. Then, the track explodes into propulsive rock (with strings). ***
2. (4:20) Classical — Lyrical and lilting, with layered instruments ranging from piano and organ to synth and discordant saxophones — all over a captivating bass line and rhythm. ****
3. (4:10) Capricorn — Starts as a gentle and melodic baroque pop sway, but after a piano-based lead break, the second verse mixes in some disquieting noise — perhaps reflecting Koenig’s observations of generational concerns, while still finding optimism in everyday details. ****
4. (5:10) Connect — Reminiscent of “Holiday” from the band’s “Contra” album. Lively and light on its feet with intricate keyboards, a skipping rhythm, jazzy vibe and synth trills and trappings.
5. (3:49) Prep-School Gangsters — Baroque pop tune built on pulsing bass line, piano, Farfisa organ, angular guitar and uplifting vocals. ****
6. (5:47) The Surfer — Languid and laid-back, with piano and other keys, shimmering synths, strings, a trip-hop beat and slow, sad guitars.
7. (3:48) Gen-X Cops — Driving, up-tempo rock with prominent guitar, almost surfy drums, chime-y synths and piano. Some distortion and effects along with harmonized vocals.
8. (4:26) Mary Boone — Builds off past Vampire Weekend favorites such as “Hannah Hunt” and “Ya Hey.” Full, rich reverbed lead vocals with a ‘chorale’ as backing, piano arpeggios and a pensively paced, shuffling beat. ****
9. (4:11) Pravda — Skipping and playful. Piano, synth and other keys — with repeated, intricate guitar runs. Call-and-response vocals. ***
10. (7:58) Hope — Epic, mesmerizing closing rock anthem. Piano over a solid beat. The lyrics speak of difficulties — real or metaphoric — while repeatedly urging “I hope you let it go.” ***
11. (3:36) Ice Cream Piano (Unedited) FCC: fuck (twice) — Unedited version of Track 1.
Vampire Weekend returns with its 5th studio album. The title is taken from a news article about an airliner whose roof blew off during a flight in Hawaii, with a passenger quoted as saying “Only God was above us.” This serves as a metaphor for singer-songwriter Ezra Koenig’s ongoing search for answers to cosmic questions regarding life and purpose. Not quite as melodic as the band’s previous “Father Of The Bride,” the album nevertheless offers a standout collection of instant indie rock and chamber pop classics that integrate exotic rhythms, multiple layers of keys, plus bass and guitar — together with Koenig’s clever, intelligent lyrics exploring wide-ranging aspects of our existence. It’s noisier and more clash-y than their previous albums, but truly, every track is worthy of play. RIYL: Vampire Weekend
— Francis
Highly recommended: 3, 8, 5, 2, 10, 9, 1. FCC on Track 11 (unedited version of track #1).
1. (3:36) Ice Cream Piano (Radio Edit) — Unexpected opener. Almost spoken vocals with a couple of expletives, set over distortion and deliberate piano. Then, the track explodes into propulsive rock (with strings). ***
2. (4:20) Classical — Lyrical and lilting, with layered instruments ranging from piano and organ to synth and discordant saxophones — all over a captivating bass line and rhythm. ****
3. (4:10) Capricorn — Starts as a gentle and melodic baroque pop sway, but after a piano-based lead break, the second verse mixes in some disquieting noise — perhaps reflecting Koenig’s observations of generational concerns, while still finding optimism in everyday details. ****
4. (5:10) Connect — Reminiscent of “Holiday” from the band’s “Contra” album. Lively and light on its feet with intricate keyboards, a skipping rhythm, jazzy vibe and synth trills and trappings.
5. (3:49) Prep-School Gangsters — Baroque pop tune built on pulsing bass line, piano, Farfisa organ, angular guitar and uplifting vocals. ****
6. (5:47) The Surfer — Languid and laid-back, with piano and other keys, shimmering synths, strings, a trip-hop beat and slow, sad guitars.
7. (3:48) Gen-X Cops — Driving, up-tempo rock with prominent guitar, almost surfy drums, chime-y synths and piano. Some distortion and effects along with harmonized vocals.
8. (4:26) Mary Boone — Builds off past Vampire Weekend favorites such as “Hannah Hunt” and “Ya Hey.” Full, rich reverbed lead vocals with a ‘chorale’ as backing, piano arpeggios and a pensively paced, shuffling beat. ****
9. (4:11) Pravda — Skipping and playful. Piano, synth and other keys — with repeated, intricate guitar runs. Call-and-response vocals. ***
10. (7:58) Hope — Epic, mesmerizing closing rock anthem. Piano over a solid beat. The lyrics speak of difficulties — real or metaphoric — while repeatedly urging “I hope you let it go.” ***
11. (3:36) Ice Cream Piano (Unedited) FCC: fuck (twice) — Unedited version of Track 1.
Recent airplay
Hope, Classical
Music Casserole — Oct 11, 2025
Prep-School Gangsters
KZSU Time Traveler — Jun 20, 2025
Mary Boone
KZSU Time Traveler — Jan 17, 2025
Prep-School Gangsters
KZSU Time Traveler — Jul 19, 2024
Prep-School Gangsters
entropy — Jul 10, 2024
Gen-X Cops
Music Casserole — Jul 06, 2024
Charting
2024-04-28 — 2024-06-30
| Week Ending | Airplays |
|---|---|
| Jun 30 | 2 |
| Jun 23 | 3 |
| Jun 16 | 3 |
| Jun 9 | 2 |
| Jun 2 | 3 |
| May 26 | 4 |
| May 19 | 2 |
| May 12 | 1 |
Track listing
| 1. | Ice Cream Piano (Radio Edit) | 3:36 | |
| 2. | Classical | 4:20 | |
| 3. | Capricorn | 4:10 | |
| 4. | Connect | 5:10 | |
| 5. | Prep-School Gangsters | 3:49 | |
| 6. | The Surfer | 5:47 | |
| 7. | Gen-X Cops | 3:48 | |
| 8. | Mary Boone | 4:26 | |
| 9. | Pravda | 4:11 | |
| 10. | Hope | 7:58 | |
| 11. | Ice Cream Piano (Unedited) |
