This Good Thing
General
| Aug 2004
Reviews
Guest DJ Account
Reviewed 2004-12-02
Reviewed 2004-12-02
Traditional ska with some rocksteady and early reggae thrown in, faithfully playing authentic Jamaican rhythms topped by distinctly American-style songwriting and vocals that often dominate the songs. By no means an American ska classic, but superior trombone work and precise Jamaican rhythms make a few tracks worth a listen. Produced by legendary ska musician and producer Victor Rice.
FCC Clean. Start with: 9,12,14 then: 6,11,17
Reviewed by: Coop
1. Organ-driven, fast ska, tedious reggae break from 2:50 to end.
2. Embellished by trombone outbursts, steady rhythm but much real feeling to it
3. Bouncy ska, lots of tricky drum fills, Slackers knock-off, especially in vocal
4. *Soulful vocal, good trombone soloing, fun dance number
5. Rocksteady, Upsetters-style reggae intro, competent vocal harmonies, organ bubbling in background
6. *Trombone leads this uptempo ska shaker
7. Annoying/whiney vocals over skinhead reggae rhythm
8. Spooky organ over fast ska, Spaghetti Western guitar solo mid-song
9. **Fast ska with roots rock and roll influence, sing along chorus, danceable, potentially irritating as vocals sound like a Beastie Boy singing ska karaoke, fun song overall
10. Dub Reggae
11. *Fast ska, dark-sounding organ and vocals, danceable
12. **Smooth, early-reggae/rock steady chill-out tune, percussion and horn lines lend a Latin/Cuban Jazz feeling
13. Fast ska, reminiscent of early Toasters songs, fed-up sing along chorus
14. **Rhythmically-dense reggae cut, simple-but-enjoyable lyrics about finding worth in being dumped by a greedy girlfriend, chill-out track
15. Fun mid-tempo ska, clean lyrics possibly about pedophilia/Lolita relationship
16. Mid-tempo ska with slow intro and breakdowns, honky-tonkish influence
17. *Instrumental version of old standard, trombone does usual vocal parts, suprisingly effective
18. Effects-laden dub version of Track 17, unnecessary, stick to Track 17
19. Dub of track 9, intro to 54 sec., followed by silence/worthless hidden track, avoid this one.
FCC Clean. Start with: 9,12,14 then: 6,11,17
Reviewed by: Coop
1. Organ-driven, fast ska, tedious reggae break from 2:50 to end.
2. Embellished by trombone outbursts, steady rhythm but much real feeling to it
3. Bouncy ska, lots of tricky drum fills, Slackers knock-off, especially in vocal
4. *Soulful vocal, good trombone soloing, fun dance number
5. Rocksteady, Upsetters-style reggae intro, competent vocal harmonies, organ bubbling in background
6. *Trombone leads this uptempo ska shaker
7. Annoying/whiney vocals over skinhead reggae rhythm
8. Spooky organ over fast ska, Spaghetti Western guitar solo mid-song
9. **Fast ska with roots rock and roll influence, sing along chorus, danceable, potentially irritating as vocals sound like a Beastie Boy singing ska karaoke, fun song overall
10. Dub Reggae
11. *Fast ska, dark-sounding organ and vocals, danceable
12. **Smooth, early-reggae/rock steady chill-out tune, percussion and horn lines lend a Latin/Cuban Jazz feeling
13. Fast ska, reminiscent of early Toasters songs, fed-up sing along chorus
14. **Rhythmically-dense reggae cut, simple-but-enjoyable lyrics about finding worth in being dumped by a greedy girlfriend, chill-out track
15. Fun mid-tempo ska, clean lyrics possibly about pedophilia/Lolita relationship
16. Mid-tempo ska with slow intro and breakdowns, honky-tonkish influence
17. *Instrumental version of old standard, trombone does usual vocal parts, suprisingly effective
18. Effects-laden dub version of Track 17, unnecessary, stick to Track 17
19. Dub of track 9, intro to 54 sec., followed by silence/worthless hidden track, avoid this one.
Recent airplay
Rock-N-Ska
Dollar Bin — Nov 29, 2004
Artificial Tears
Morning Glory — Nov 27, 2004
Wonderful World
Dross — Nov 24, 2004
Rock-N-Ska
Storytime! — Nov 23, 2004
Charting
2004-11-22 — 2005-01-24
| Week Ending | Airplays |
|---|---|
| Dec 5 | 1 |
| Nov 28 | 3 |
Track listing
| 1. | Get Away | ||
| 2. | Miss Melodrama | ||
| 3. | Being Deceived | ||
| 4. | In the End | ||
| 5. | This Good Thing | ||
| 6. | Telephone Breakdown | ||
| 7. | Your Patient Ways | ||
| 8. | Artificial Tears | ||
| 9. | Rock-N-Ska | ||
| 10. | The Story | ||
| 11. | Stop Thinking | ||
| 12. | Just Ain't Right | ||
| 13. | You Naggin' Me | ||
| 14. | Rich Boy | ||
| 15. | She's My Only 16 | ||
| 16. | Belly Rubbin | ||
| 17. | Wonderful World | ||
| 18. | Wonderful Dub | ||
| 19. | Rock-N-Ska Dub |